Hacker News Reader

Comment by simulate | Hacker News Reader

Slate columnist Sara Dickerman wrote a critique of pepper as a table spice a few years ago, while acknowledging its historical medicinal qualities, as the OP does:

> Why should this brawny spice be kept on the countertop at all? Why not stash it in the rack with the fennel seed, the mustard seed, and the cinnamon—all the wonderful spices that add life to our food but are by no means all-purpose? I think we’d appreciate pepper's qualities all the more if we used it just for specific dishes, not universally.

http://www.slate.com/articles/life/food/2012/01/salt_and_pep...

View on HN

I like having pepper in a shaker on the table because it improves every food I add it to. But it hasn’t occurred to me that might just be a weird bias.

Instead of hiding pepper away on the spice rack, why not bring more spices to the table? Get 5 or 6 more salt shakers, fill them with additional spices, put them on the dining table, and try them with different foods. Could be a fun way to learn more about flavors when cooking at home.

I have a spice blend that I made for flavoring beans that has kind of become a new staple at the table. It's about half tomato powder, maybe a quarter hot red chile powder, and equal parts cumin, onion powder, garlic powder, and oregano for the balance. I'm thinking about switching some of the chile powder out for chipotle to see how that goes for the next batch.

Two teaspoons in a bowl of beans makes some nice ranch-style beans, but we've been using it in lots of other places as a shake-on spice (eggs are particularly good). It's a pretty decent dry rub for meat on the smoker or grill too.

If you mean literally a shaker, I'd highly recommend getting a grinder even if it's one of those disposable ones built into the bottle. One of my pet peeves (#FirstWorldProblems I know) is restaurants, especially those at the mid- to high-end, with pepper shakers.

I've been refilling the same McCormick grinder for a decade now. There is no comparison between freshly ground and pre-ground pepper, even if the peppercorns have been sitting around a while.

You should try upgrading to a proper mill. Those McCormick grinders just kind of crush the corns into little pieces, a real grinder can produce a powerfully pungent powder that will really knock your socks off.

A pepper mill is one of those things that you should upgrade first in your kitchen, right up there with your chef's knife.

Thanks for the tip!

My wife and I never eat with fewer than six herb/spice jars and/or condiments at our table. Exactly which ones vary from meal to meal, and there is no guarantee that either of us uses a given spice. (I've been on a fines herbes kick lately, and balsamic glaze is a perennial guest.) Black pepper is present less often than not, but it's used deliberately when it is.

We think we're weird, but I would be glad to know we aren't unique. Spices are the spice of life!

> Why not stash it in the rack with the fennel seed, the mustard seed, and the cinnamon

Interestingly, people kept a third shaker with their salt and pepper as late as the mid-1850's. No one is sure what it was commonly used for, but it might have been powdered mustard.

Based on the literature, it was almost certainly mustard.

1823: https://books.google.com/books?id=02gUAAAAQAAJ&dq=cruet%20st...

1857: https://books.google.com/books?id=IXkEAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA255&dq=c...

1893: https://books.google.com/books?id=gRM-AQAAMAAJ&dq=cruet%20sa...

I've often wondered why this spice, out of all possible spices (or spice blends), has such primacy in at least Western cooking and eating.

Most spices can't be added after cooking so there's that

Salt and pepper both enhance the flavor of food without changing the taste or adding additional flavors, in my opinion, which makes both of them maximally versatile and leads to their primacy.

However, I'm curious now if my assessment of black pepper as unflavored is due to just eating so much of it through my life that I don't realize it has a taste.

Black pepper definitely has a taste, like I can taste it on food and I add more when it's needed. Try tasting a steak and then add some pepper and see if you can't literally taste it, or even try it with bread or rice or anything really. Or have I just gone mad?

I personally can’t taste black pepper, although I enjoy the smell. But I once asked my parents about this and they both said they definitely could taste it.

It may be that the zesty quality of pepper outpaces any taste. I’m curious to put it on something bland now to see if I can taste it, but my original comment was meant to convey that I might be blind to the actual taste of black pepper as a result of its cultural omnipresence.

It also loses some of its flavor - but keeps its bite - as it ages too much. Particularly after grinding. Try it with freshly purchased, fresh ground.

It is said that Louis XIV preferred pepper, and this preference is what lead to pepper's eventual dominance in the West.

I don't have a great source for this, but here's a gizmodo article... https://gizmodo.com/how-salt-and-pepper-became-the-yin-and-y...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com