Understanding schizophrenia: What exactly is schizophrenia?
paulmorrison.org
paulmorrison.org
I didn't trust that western psychiatry could heal the underlying causes so I basically just shut up about it for a decade.
After about 10 years, I was suicidal and couldn't ignore it anymore.
My intuition told me to find another way, so I started to research on my own. I found a way through that involved MDMA therapy, NARM therapy, holotropic breathwork, and creating a loving romantic relationship.
I now live symptom-free, with no medication, and am really grateful I trusted my intuition and made my own path.
A person close to me is suffering from schizophrenia. We found, to our surprise, that anti-psychotic medications work very well. It changes a person who is not able to function (delusions, disorganized speech, unable to focus or carry conversation, very poor judgement and actions that result in total loss of all possessions and homelessness) back to a person we know well and who can be a normal member of society.
Unfortunately, they don't recognize any of their past symptoms. Eventually they stop taking medication (which is logical on their part, because why would you take medication, if you are not sick?), and a scary slide back begins.
Imagine, if sometime last week, family or friends came to you and told you that you have schizophrenia, and that you should take medication because you have delusions. You don't know what they are talking about. If this happened to you, what would you do? This is the situation many find themselves in.
For any mentally healthy person out there who finds themselves surrounded by loved ones telling them they may have schizophrenia and to please get treatment - please do, even if that sounds ridiculous to you. If you are on and off medication, keep a journal to record how you feel. Do not rely on your own judgement alone - please listen to your friends and loved ones.
I've never suffered from depression before, so I hadn't been aware of how depressed I had gotten while taking amlodopine. After switching, I checked the known side effects and sure enough depression is one of them -- to the point where some countries have disallow its use!
It really surprised me how much this drug affected my life without my noticing anything out of the ordinary. What's even more interesting is that this summer I got very stressed about work (something that has never actually happened before) and ended up having a panic attack. So now I'm wondering about the new medication! It's crazy.
The big thing that I keep thinking about is, how much of my state of mind is "me" and how much is my medication (or any other things, like drinking coffee, or beer, or not exercising enough, or whatever). It's made me much more conscious about monitoring my mental state and taking some actions rather than just assuming everything is OK. But it's incredibly scary. I've had quite a few friends with mental illnesses and this helps me understand a tiny bit better what they are going through.
Oh, and +1,000,000 on the journal. It's the only way I can keep track of what's going on in my head.
I think of it as "ignorance broad enough to encompass one's ignorance" or "to not know _that_ one doesn't know"
Meaning that I didn’t try to convince people they were wrong in classifying what they saw through their paradigm, but rather took it up as my work to navigate from that point forward.
I also began to see “mental illness” as a context vs. some discrete thing inside ones brain. And that many of the symptoms an individual is experiencing are manifesting for the collective.
An example of this is imagine a father who grows up with a mother with intense and dangerous rage.
He will very often never learn to feel his own rage in a healthy way. He meets a woman and they have kids.
He spends so much time avoiding his own rage that it begins to show up in his wife and family. He tries to control it in them as well, making sure no one feels it.
Perhaps one kid ends up diagnosed with depression due to not having a safe context to feel emotion in the home.
The mother escapes into work.
The child, never having felt safe with the father ends up angry as an adult and violent toward the father.
The mother becomes rageful with the father as well for not having a relationship with the child.
If anyone of them would goto a traditional psychiatrist they’d most likely be prescribed medication — another attempt to suppress the emotions.
If one looks at the overall system and begins to help the father heal his trauma of the rageful mother, he can begin to grieve and heal himself.
His capacity for his own anger increases and he is better able to hold space for that of his family. He can understand now why he’s felt so much anger directed at him — he recreated the rage he was accustom to as a child but now in his home as an adult.
The other family members do their own work as well and collectively the family learns deeper self regulation and connection.
Soon their entire social circle and community is beginning to transform and wake up and learning to feel more fully.
Very often a family or social system will unknowingly “push” their unfelt feelings into a single individual and then try to medicate or eliminate that individual.
In some tribal cultures they say “the schizophrenic sits at the seat no one else is willing to sit at”.
The shamanic approach acknowledges that some folks with a greater sensitivity will begin to experience the pain of the underrepresented values of the tribe.
With proper mentorship and context, that person can become a wise leader, deeply intune to the unackowleged needs of the tribe.
This was the approach I took and have continued to take with the folks and families I’ve worked with.
I start off with a position that the persons experience is inherently valueable and contains useful information for me and the community.
From there I seek to connect with the reality they are in and to join them there while still maintaining my own sense of safety. I seek to see where my own behavior could be changed in support of this person.
I also encourage the folks who care about the person to examine their own lives and see what might be connected and to work on healing it.
A fantastic book on this topic that was really helpful was Rethinking Madness by Dr. Paris Williams (you can download the PDF for free).
There are also some incredible results happening with a process called Open Dialog in which the community gets together and speaks the truth of their experience and this has incredible results.
My experience and scaffolding it left behind allow me to support some incredible people and organizations around the world in their own growth and transformation.
I’ll even be at the UN this Wednesday for a meeting on global mental health.
It is really wild to think that just a few years ago I was being told I’d be on medication the rest of my life; my girl friend at the time (a Stanford Psychiatrist) told me her advisors had said “Stanford psychiatrists don’t date men with bipolar! They never get better, they are like alcoholics!” and that she’s be ruined professionally for associating with someone who thought they could heal without medication; I was suicidal and sleeping in a vacant house in San Jose...
Now I’m living in NYC; engaged to an amazing yogi; a full practice of clients; my relationship with my family is better than ever and we just bought an Island in Panama to build a healing village.
When we go within, anything is possible!
Maybe a slightly random question, though there's a purpose for me asking: do you remember having any ear infections as a child, and were they painful at all?
Think anxiety. Or like on the movie A Beautiful Mind (I know it's a movie but it happens IRL too). Or being under the influence of some psychedelics (you know you're under the influence but it still feels like reality).
Who is then defining what is schizophrenia?
Is it a physician? Does it have any pathological evidences?
The clear answer is NO.
So it cannot be a disease.
It is defined by psychiatrists by voting the "disorders" in their meetings of American Psychiatric Association. Such disorders are then published in the Diagnostic and Statistic Manual: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diagnostic_and_Statistical_Man...
Further, by researching, one will come to conclusion that those mental disorders are added and removed as their assembly wants it. Or whatever the lobby wants.
It would be good to review the writings of Dr. Thomas Szasz:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Szasz
https://www.cchrint.org/about-us/co-founder-dr-thomas-szasz/...
For human problems there exist human solutions.
How can be a "disorder" which cannot be pathologically proven be "healed" by taking more and more drugs?
For example, I found the following texts thought provoking:
http://behaviorismandmentalhealth.com/2010/01/21/schizophren...
http://behaviorismandmentalhealth.com/2013/01/03/schizophren...
Fast forward 10 years when his mother passes away, his other family had written him off long ango, and we find our tragic hero homeless, with symptoms noticeably worse than before. being the only person he trusted, it was up to me to get him the help he needs. It was the hardest thing I've ever had to do. I gave him a room in my house, which was the least I could do really, and even helped cosign for a car. But all of this mattered little in changing his actual situation, which still seemed to be getting worse not better. The challenge for me was balancing the line between being a friend, and being just another person trying to convince him his mental model is faulty and he needs treatment. For one reason or another he absolutely refused to go. He called that place rape factory, and insisted he'd rather be homeless then spend even a single night there. And who am I to hold the definitive truth on reality? Where I saw dysfunction, he saw a "gift of sight," only a few are capable of. In the end, I'm afraid that my unwillingness to convince him he has a problem is coming more from a position of weakness rather than strength. Had I been able to convince him to get treatment, than perhaps he wouldn't be in jail today, and I wouldn't have lost the lease to my house; ultimately leading to my own homelessness to this day.
Despite all of the headaches, I learned some valuable lessons from Ben. Mostly, don't worry so much what other's think of you. Take life as it comes without being so serious all the time. And reality is not some fixed thing, and is mostly a function of the beholder.
Schizophrenia just seems like this process on overdrive where some of the key processes involved with keeping this overall process stable go awry. One of these minor processes is probably a belief process where the brain classifies things by True / not True. Since minor psychochis can occur to recreational drug users using psychedelics that make their mind more open to ideas, this seems to make sense to me.
An example would be ascribing significant meaning to an event that is random. But for the schizophrenic the event isn’t random, it’s the result of a persecutory delusion, at least in the paranoid variant. It looks very close to religious thinking, but in a negative way: “The dry cleaners I go to are secretly a front for a shady government organization that is attempting to study my every action”
In short, the top-down processing hierarchy is "the model", and the bottom-up processing hierarchy is "the evidence." The brain switches between using the evidence to train the model (when the evidence is salient and the model is weak), and using the model to predict and "fill in for" the evidence (when the model is salient and the evidence is noisy.)
It would make a lot of sense to me if psychosis were simply a result of chronically overdriven AMPA signalling, such that evidence is always being "fit to" the existing model, with the bottom-up hierarchy never being granted enough dominance to use the evidence to correct the model.
It’s interesting that to know that there might be a fairly straight forward mapping of the to brain chemistry/neural mechanisms.
Do you any references the AMPA signaling pathways and associated neurological structures that you can recommend as a starting point?
https://nutritionandmetabolism.biomedcentral.com/articles/10...
https://www.schres-journal.com/article/S0920-9964(15)30041-4...
Not to mention all of the other variables to check, such as simply putting less energy into food prep (less stress) and so on.
But first, the authors are confused. All brains (100%) contain macrophages in proximity to neurons. Specifically microglia (which are macrophages) and perivascular macrophages.
Second, note that they studied cases already selected to be in a high inflammatory state.
Third, they do not show the direction of causality. It’s easy to imagine how a life lived with schizophrenia could substantially increase your risk of inflammation.
Schizophrenia is a manifestation of "stress" (infections/drug use/injuries/emotions/malnourishment/etc) that's worsened by standard treatments. Some of the drugs used to treat "psychosis" seem to cause inflammation. Patients treated with anti-psychotics have been found to suffer more deterioration than those who are never treated with anti-psychotics.
My friend was eating a lot of soybean oil and alcohol in the months before she was captured by the mental health industry. Soybean oil is a source of Omega-6 oil, which breaks down into inflammatory prostaglandins. Alcohol contributes to inflammation too. Instead of treating the causes of her presentation, the professionals treat her symptoms. At one point they tried to label her "schizophrenic".
Sometimes medical diagnoses are helpful. The diagnosis of "schizophrenia" is a non-helpful medical curse. There are some good psychiatrists, but the profession desperately needs help.
Any tips for lowering inflammation? I only know of these; lower intake of alcohol, sleep well, kurkuma, aspirin.
Just as a datapoint, I suffer from psychosis and experience a good response to aspirin.
Also, take a glycine supplement or drink lots of bone broth to boost your glutathione levels (your body's natural antioxidant). Muscle meat has glycine in it too, but most of it goes towards counteracting the methionine that's also in muscle meat.
THC delivers the high in the weed. I know people who use pot, but I stay far away from it.
I think people have an idea of what schizophrenia looks like but they might be surprised by other very closely related disorders.