Sigh.
Sigh.
However, the generally accepted quote syntax on HN does not use code blocks in the first place.
> *Quote goes here*Some users don't, there is no one unambiguously correct method, and the 2nd- most common variant I see has several obvious detriments.
The fact that the "show us your code" feature seems to be predominantly used for blockquotes, on a generally technological site, strongly suggests a failure to correctly match user expectations and needs.
Though as metacommentary in infotech, SV, and YC, the message couldn't be clearer.
Seems more likely that it's a lack of instruction on the comment page. Discord manages to fit all of its formatting into the whitespace under the chat input....
Format your posts appropriately - that's the sole burden of the writer, no one else's.
Don't blame the user.
I don't think the major problem is that `/^ {4}/` lines don't wrap in a way that's useful for quotes; it's that there's no way to format quotes so people use the only formatting element HN has.
Technically, HN has a couple other formatting elements.
It is a standing convention to use the following syntax for quotes here:
> *Quote text here* pre { whitespace: pre-wrap; }
https://www.w3schools.com/cssref/pr_text_white-space.aspThat's what I've included in my own HN Stylus stylesheet for years. Works on Desktop or Firefox/Android, but other mobile browsers don't support it, for lack of extension support.
Updating the HN markup to offer true blockquote support would be a more complete, though less trivial, solution.
I've suggested the first myself repeatedly.
pg asked how to fix this, and was given the solution, on HN, nine years ago:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=592603
The suggestion's been made numerous times:
https://hn.algolia.com/?query=whitespace%20pre-wrap&sort=byP...