Show HN: Share, organize and discover what your friends are seeing on the web | Hacker News Reader

Show HN: Share, organize and discover what your friends are seeing on the web

thesharedweb.com

14 pointsnicoslepicos13 comments

Hey HN,

My co-founders and I have been working on a project for the last month or so, and we'd like to get your input on it. We wanted to hear your thoughts on what we're doing - so check out our landing page, and let us know what you think/understand.

Does it sounds like something you guys would want to use?

http://www.thesharedweb.com/alpha/intro

We'll tell you guys more about exactly what we're doing as the conversation evolves, but we just wanted to see what the initial reaction is, and what you understand (i.e. are we describing it in a way that makes sense).

Really excited to hear your thoughts!

Cheers, Nicolae, Kareem and Nav

Open articleView on HN

I like it. I like it mostly because I love Google reader, but all the RSS feeds can be hard to manage when I want to go back and find something I read (usually a recipe I tagged). This is sort of like a reader for links? Seems easier to organize, which is cool.

My only question is, what is the incentive for people to organize information? If I have already read it, or seen it, why do I care if its neatly filed away? I think you need to give people more incentive to curate their links- so they are inspired to pick cool ones, organize them, annotate them, and then share them. If they just use the shared web to collect links, it could quickly become the mess (similar to my reader) and then it loses utility.

I think if you can answer the question about "why do I organize?" this will be awesome, The more effort you can get people to put into the "curate" part- the cooler your platform becomes.

Hey Sarah,

Thanks so much for your feedback. The way we think about it - there's two reasons to organize the thing's you've seen. Self-reference for later, and also, just so your friends have a place to browse it if they want to. I could tell a friend, yah go check out all the advice I've read on pitching - there's lots of good stuff there in my 'pitching' channel :). For those people, they now have a place to browse what you've seen, and they can thank you for posting it, and respond.

The nice thing, is that we're working on ways to make the categorization as automatic as possible (e.g. via crowdsourcing etc) - so that for you its easy to say you saw it, and then it goes into the appropriate topic.

We're also thinking about the ways to differentiate between the links that stand out, and the ones that don't in the long term. For example, based on your friends' reaction to it, your own indication of its importance, and other metrics. That way, this becomes a more useful showcase and memory of your web experience.

I think social sharing is a good first start- people like the stuff their friends like. For example, I might read your facebook feed (if I didn't hate facebook) because I know you, but I'm not going to go read some randos facebook feed. That would just be boring. and weird.

My point is, social only gets you so far. You share with your friends, your friends share with you- but then it actually does break down. If you look at preceieved sense of authority, trust drops almost 2 fold when its a "friend of a friend- instead of a friend. You run the risk of having all of these "cells of authority" that don't interact.

But the good news is, traditional forms of authority can solve this problem. People seek out and read content all of the time that isn't recommended by their friends. They read it because they think its a good source of information. And because they think the person who is writing it is an authority (or at least entertaining).

I think you want to make sure that your platform encourages this kind of authrity as well. You want people to have shared web channels that people read like they read tech crunch or the wall street journal. This is important because 90% of all content consumers (and in my opinion, its really more like 99%) are passive. All they do is read. They don't create. They don't share.

But the do click your ads. So its smart to think about how this product is for them.

Also, we'll look into annotation - curious if you can tell us more about how and why you'd use it :).

I don't get it. What is it that you do exactly? All I see is a bunch of marketing text that anyone could have put together. "Show your friends what you're doing!" I'm already doing that - in email, on Facebook, on Twitter, etc. What do you do that makes that experience better?

Your landing page is pure fluff - there isn't an ounce of actual value on it. Anyone can have an idea - and your landing page just seems like "Hey - I had this cool idea of, 'What if you could maybe like do this cool stuff with all this other cool stuff? Like, that would be cool, right?"

Too abstract and not enough concrete. Or, to put it another way, why are you showing us now? Why not wait until you at least have a screenshot?

Part of this looks interesting - is this making it easier for me to organize my browsing? I've been trying to keep track of links for a work project as I browse, would this make it easier for me to store those sites to share or find later? That could be hugely useful.

Or does this make it easier to share those links with other people? If it's just for sharing, I can't tell if it's like Shareaholic or something new.

I'm having a hard time figuring out if this is more for publicly sharing content/links or if it's for my personal storage and organizing? Looks interesting enough for me to look at the beta - send it my way if you want.

Hey HN,

My cofounders and I have been working on a project for the last month or so, and we'd like to get your input on it. We wanted to hear your thoughts on what we're doing - so check out our landing page, and let us know what you think/understand. Does it sounds like something you guys would want to use?

Really excited to hear your thoughts!

Cheers, Nicolae, Kareem and Nav

The logo looks like you copied peerindex.net

Hi Noel,

Thanks for pointing that out. We had never seen peerindex.net before. Its eerie how close our choice of colors is and styling is. They are also in a very similar market and their thought process is very close to ours. We'll make sure to keep this in mind before we launch.

How do we check it out?

You can check it out here:

http://www.thesharedweb.com/alpha/intro

>> How do we check it out?

I think he meant if he could test drive the service, instead of a landing page that's just some copywriting

this looks sick. i like it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com