I don't see why this method in particular would be a problem with regards to achieving the goal. Enforcing copyright laws through traditional lawsuits and criminal law enforcement has been, by and large, a failure. We do need a change in the enforcement methods, as it's very clear the laws will not be adjusted to match the reality of rampant piracy.

In the end, changing the method of enforcement it's just another method to make law and reality match up (as opposed to changing the laws to reflect reality).