Reddit Experiencing Elevated Error Rates
reddit.statuspage.io
reddit.statuspage.io
You're right, though. This might finally be enough to break me free of that particular Skinner box.
Dark patterns like the big red button saying "CONTINUE" that opens the App Store, instead of letting you continue on the website.
The "redesign" is a buggy waste of screen space which loads noticeably slower and also, I think, prevents subreddits from having rich sidebars or custom themes, hindering the original promise of serving unique sub-communities.
I always use "old.reddit.com" to force the "classic" site but it still keeps jumping back to the redesign in some places like certain user profiles.
This frontend assault combined with the deplorable meatspace behavior like the Reddit admin(s) secretly editing user comments [0], threatening better apps for "stealing" their icon [1], among other scumminess [2], I think it's nigh approaching its Digg Moment.
[0] https://www.google.com/search?q=Reddit+admin+editing+comment...
[1] https://old.reddit.com/r/apolloapp/comments/7l2ank/rip_good_...
[2] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/07/reddi...
To respond seriously, I don't see the point in competing against Reddit for Redditors. What are you trying to achieve?
HN is already a much better place for certain topics, for example, but we need a more general platform.
- /u/sodypop (Reddit Admin)
There was no follow up from that Aug 15th outage, at-least as far as I can see via their social-media accounts. https://twitter.com/redditstatus
I don't see that as useless? Unless you are talking about such a system for the internal infra team. I doubt that they are looking at this public-facing "traffic light status" page, however.
The problem I see with a lot of sites is that there is plainly a problem, but the status is still green. I was checking reddit's status page and Aug 20th was green throughout the entire downtime and still is. The amount of times I've seen it be inaccurate makes me think it is not a good model.
I would much rather have a graph of requests served and other metrics (which reddit has). You can very clearly see a dive on the graphs and know something is wrong.
This is what I'm referring to: https://i.imgur.com/UAtFnfI.jpg
The cynic in me says that these companies want to get away with not making any public statement about having an outage unless they absolutely have to. That's certainly the way it was when I worked in web hosting, the bosses would take every opportunity to avoid reporting incidents if nobody complained.
We've all seen the infamous AWS "all agreen" status page while an entire region is melting. Stripe have been slow on acknowledging their API being broken and then later deleted their eventual Tweets admitting a problem. I've sat in the Linode IRC channel with staff members acknowledging outages for the better part of an hour without Twitter or the status sites updated.
What's going on? Your engineers shouldn't have the status site and remediation competing for their time and attention. Either hook the status site up to Prometheus/Pingdom and deal with the occasional false positive, or sort your customer communication out.
Infuriating as a user and customer. Makes me really appreciate companies like OVH which have comprehensive public smokeping metrics in every region from many ASes.
But keeping a "everything's OK" flag flying is a big part of a marketing image. I hate this too, but I get why they do it. A status page that shows things are constantly 1-10% broken doesn't inspire confidence.
For example the AWS "all green" event you mention, misleading public-facing information is the bread and butter of the seemingly never-ending line of people that want to browbeat me about switching to $cloud_service_x. I'm not saying AWS isn't great, nor making a point specifically about AWS, but how do you convince people that they're a better cost:value ratio than having a good ops team that keeps our internal-facing services redundant across the basements of the three buildings closest to me? By pretending like the fires don't happen and hiding the ops cost behind ridiculous hourly hardware rates.
[1] http://web.mit.edu/2.75/resources/random/How%20Complex%20Sys...
The CEO actively instigates political campaigns and stirs up drama on Reddit just like every news site does. I hate politics; I don't work for free.
Besides, I learn more from one comment here than thousands on Reddit. Most of it is memes and meta-jokes, there's little information anymore. It's the antithesis of efficiency, times change.