Hacker News Reader

Comment by curtisblaine | Hacker News Reader

Edit: it seems the story has been unflagged. I'm kinda confused in how the whole thing works.

I now flagged it, 21 upvotes, and it went into flagged mode again. No idea how many flags cancel out upvotes or how the algorithm really works.

In my opinion that's entertainment news, not hackernews material. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html "Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon."

Some topics, scandals, even catastrophes are usually completely ignored on HN. The idea is that other websites, the main stream media and large newspaper, sufficiently cover it.

I'm not arguing against the story itself. I've read it in the newspaper this morning. Just my expectation when opening HN is not to see/discuss a celebrity paying off a rape victim, regardless the circumstances that led to act. Actually I'm surprised the Weinstein story made the frontpage.

Yet a lot of Weinstein stories weren't flagged and two made the frontpage. Looks like bias, so was asking if this kind of implicit bias was common in HN. You flagged Argento's story, did you flag Weinstein's too when it came out?

You may want to re-read the guidelines. Especially the bit about emailing the mods.

I'm not asking the mods why Argento's story was flagged. I'm asking the community if HN has a double standard on what news are "acceptable".

Yet again, you don't understand flagging.

You probably already know the answer. There is certainly a liberal bias in the readership and that bias in naturally reflected in what is flagged.

I'm not sure that's true. Every single post about climate change or global warming, for instance--no matter how tech-related the story may happen to be--gets flagged almost immediately. That's not being done by liberals.

I vouched it, that's why it was unflagged. I thought it was an interesting other perspective, regardless of which "side" you believe.

Thanks!

Still flagged though :(

It has been flagged again

Reply on news.ycombinator.com