That bullshit gets trotted out with some regularity but it is clearly nonsense.
Have a read here and draw your own conclusions:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_Cochabamba_protests
If someone owns a resource they have an interest in extracting maximum value out of it, not in preserving it.
I've seen the case made for private ownership of air and water and I think it is utter rubbish. What we need instead is good stewardship of our natural resources, a way to extract tax on the depletion of natural resources instead of on production of value.