Hacker News Reader

Does the Nike swoosh pass your test? The brand is the logo, not the other way around. So this would stand out, if MySpace was doing something great. If a logo is supposed to make all impact by itself, and not by the content of the brand – a bright cyan logo with sharp objects would be the best logo..

View on HN

The problem is they're trying to do both. Its half graphic, half wordmark. Nike's graphic and its wordmark can survive on their own or appear together. The same can't be said of this. MySpace can't put ____ somewhere and expect people to immediately associate it with MySpace, no matter how much advertising they do to try to ingrain it. Nor can they use "My" alone and expect people to know they really mean "MySpace".

Its just a jolting experience. It invites you to start reading it, which you do, and then you run into this underline shape.

That's true, and I agree. I just commented on parent posters litmus test.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com