Hacker News Reader

I've never liked that witticism. For one thing it breaks down really quickly - ie by that logic Welsh is a dialect of English, and Walloon French is a dialect of Flemish. It's also fairly irrelevant to me what a government thinks is a dialect when I want to discuss languages. IE ethnic chinese can call languages that are mutually unintelligable 'dialects' all they want, it doesn't change reality.

View on HN

The Yiddish original, "a shprakh iz a dialekt mit an armey un flot", was targeted at people who refused to view Yiddish as an independent language, but rather just as a dialect of German. The point was that if Yiddish-speakers had their own country, those people wouldn't have said that.

Similarly, I've heard several non-Bavarian Germans claiming Bavarian isn't a language, while the Bavarians claim it is.

People use it like it's a rule, but it was more a specific quip about Yiddish, and how many saw it as a dialect of German, rather than a distinct language.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com