Hacker News Reader

Comment by emisario | Hacker News Reader

"But the striking thing to me is just how much smaller the Intel NUC is."

Add the volume of the NUC's hideous and ungainly power supply brick. Then make your judgement on size.

If you've taken a mini apart, you'd see that the easiest way volume could be significantly reduced is by replacing the space for two 3.5" drives with space for one modern NVME gum stick - a trick which the already NUC does thanks to its being developed more recently.

The mini has Thunderbolt and and digital audio in/out. The NUC has neither of these.

If you compare the interior of the mini and the NUC, the NUC does not stand out as an marvel of engineering or miniaturization.

Anyway, whose desk cannot fit a mac mini?

View on HN

It's not about desks, really.

Sufficiently-small-form-factor computers become "AIO enablement dongles", in the sense that you can stick one to the back of a monitor or TV (much like a "compute stick") and now that monitor or TV is an AIO PC. People use NUCs in that use-case quite a lot.

Sufficiently-SFF computers are also used as kiosks, for POS systems, and other embedded use-cases. This isn't really the "pitch" behind the Mac Mini, but it's something the NUC is quite good at.

I really don't understand how people can put up with these huge power bricks. Just because you can hide it under a desk it doesn't mean it's not there.

And speaking of all in ones, the iMac doesn't have a power brick either. If you screw your NUC to the back of a monitor/tv you will end up with two power bricks if you're unlucky. They may fit under the desk, or the cable may be too short and you'd have to keep one or both on the desk. I don't see the advantage.

Apple has other, significant problems right now, but the devices not being mini enough isn't one of them.

Every Mac I've every seen can message with a huge power brick, often integrated directly into the plug.

I can't plug my MacBook in under my desk because it's one two-pronged and it's super heavy so it falls down.

I don't care if it has a power brick or not, just make it easy to plug in. Bonus: a cable material that is designed to withstand years of use not months; their cables are no better than the competition and they have a crazy failure rate.

Those Mac wall-wart chargers are awful. You essentially have to buy the extension cable, and voila, you have a bulkier version of the power adapter every laptop comes with.

And how in the world do they not have a grounded plug?

Things that use less than 100 W usually don't.

Because they're double insulated, so no need for ground. Also with UK plugs (The superior plug type) the apple chargers are pretty great, no way they're falling out the wall then. With the US plug they're pretty annoying though. But I have to say I do prefer the extension (which I luckily have from previous Macs).

I (resident in the US) have replaced all my outlets with universal sockets, and routinely use the U.K. style plug on my Apple power supplies.

I thought this thread was about desktops. You did know that Apple sells some desktops? For example the Mac Mini, about which the original article is complaining for the wrong reasons (I agree the hardware inside is painfully obsolete and no one should buy a mac mini atm).

The Intel NUC is also a desktop (well, non battery operated) computer, not a laptop.

I have a NUC plugged to my TV. I'm glad the NUC is small because I need it accessible for the ports and power button.

I don't care about the big power brick because it's hidden behind my TV desk along with my other power bricks (game console, sound system, etc.)

xbox owner :) The playstations don't have power bricks either.

> The mini has Thunderbolt and and digital audio in/out. The NUC has neither of these.

The NUC I am using at the moment (a NUC7I5BNK) has Thunderbolt 3.

The current Mac mini is stuck with Thunderbolt 2 and doesn't have any USB-C ports either.

I've seen many a power brick in my time, and some were ugly, but hideous seems excessive even for the worst of them.

The Intel NUC has a VESA bracket, so you can mount your monitor to the NUC. Who needs a desk, you've now got an All-In-One.

They don't want to make it NVME only, because they don't want to make a cheap Mac Mini with SSD, because it would eat into their iMac sales.

Right now the Mac Mini starts at £479, but the cheapest with a SSD is £859, don't forget that's without a keyboard/mouse/keyboard.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com