My IDE allows me to easily annotate each line with author and commit message. Invaluable information.
I have a 1500LOC files with 1100 revisions right here, "git annotate" processes it in 2.356 seconds on a 2010 MBP, and PyCharm barely takes any longer (maybe 3s).
> How is my IDE supposed to know which of those revisions are the ones that I care about?
It does not care, it gives you a baseline annotation and if that's too recent you drill down into previous annotations.
No thanks. I’d rather have a comment inline in the code than add 3 seconds per file, and still have to go searching through the history.
Or as I've encountered on multiple occasions: your IT team is struggling to figure out why your network/version control/etc are extremely slow... 3 second queries are now taking 60 seconds... we will be rebooting servers a few times... and restoring backups... hopefully things are working better tomorrow!
Or what happens when you migrate to another versioning system? Where I was working migrated from MS SourceSafe years ago and a lot of comment history was lost in the conversion and apparently it wasn't worth the time/money to figure out why only half the comments made it over.
I'm sure there are more scenarios.
The point is: comments in plain-text source files can be invaluable.
Which is exacerbated by everyone's IDE now querying VC for every file!
More often than not, you only need a few jumps before reaching the change you're interested in.