Hacker News Reader

Comment by moduspwnens14 | Hacker News Reader

Using the secure enclave, you (as a developer) can have it generate a private key you'll never be able to get and then ask it to sign / encrypt (symmetrically) arbitrary things for you.

https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certifica...

AFAIK that means it'll take more than a jailbreak to get to them, although I don't know if OTP apps are using that capability or not.

View on HN

Sadly, the Secure Enclave doesn't support HMAC-SHA-1 or importing keys [1] so it's not compatible with the industry standard TOTP 2fa mechanism.

[1] https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certifica...

I think we can do a lot better than the industry standard TOTP 2fa system anyway. TOTP involves sending plaintext private keys around during setup.

Fortunately, we have WebAuthn now. Hopefully Apple will jump on board soon.

Given that TOTP (one of the more common phone OTP methods, used by Google Authenticator) uses a symmetric key, it seems unlikely it’s being stored in the Secure Enclave

It may just require an extra step. My understanding of TOTP is that it's the key data (typically a string represented by a QR code) and a time offset that is used to generate the OTP. If the only thing stored on disk is the code encrypted by the secure enclave's key, and the only way the decrypted code is in memory at runtime is if it's decrypted by the secure enclave's key, then that still offers protection against some attack vectors.

You (as an attacker) could then recover the key if you had full control of the OS and could trick the user into authenticating so the secure enclave decrypts the key, but would presumably have more trouble if you (as as attacker) simply stole the device.

You as an attacker would arguably have just as much trouble simply unlocking the device, you'd be left with the same amount of protection approximately. As long as you have disk encryption, the security margin would be about the same. A marginal improvement at best.

>AFAIK that means it'll take more than a jailbreak to get to them, although I don't know if OTP apps are using that capability or not.

sure, you wouldn't be able to extract the keys, but what's preventing you from generating thousands of codes and extracting those instead? since they're time based, you could easily generate lots of them for a long time into the future (eg. 10 per day for the next 5 years). that should afford you plenty of opportunities to do a login attempt.

This can't be used directly for generating OTP tokens (see the other comments), but what would stop you with a normal key on the secure enclave is that you can require the enclave itself requires a higher level of authentication (facial scan match, fingerprint scan) to perform those key operations.

Yes, that's great for asymmetric stuff, but we're talking about TOTP, which uses a fixed symmetric key and a hashing algorithm. Unless you can run arbitrary code on the secure element, like you can with Intel and Qualcomm stuff it can't be done and even if it can be, it'd be a significant effort investment for what's probably a negligible secure it gain in practice. Still, I'd be pretty impressed if any apps did so.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com