Hacker News Reader

Comment by aurailious | Hacker News Reader

Duplex will definitely be used in the opposite direction than demonstrated. Its acceptable to talk to a robot over the phone, and improving that process is very valuable.

But having a robot speak to the business? That might be a bit much. Then again, if this version is only for appointments, reservations, etc, than that might be seen as acceptable in kind of the same way.

It's mostly the hesitation about when this starts going beyond that. Do you now use Google assistant to talk to friends/coworkers? "Ok, Google, ask $friend if he wants to see a movie this weekend."

View on HN

It won't be annoying, because the other person is going to want to have an AI screen their phone calls and the two systems can just figure out the most likely time the humans want to hang out and then get them to confirm.

Employing an AI to be your personal assistant is at least as moral as employing a human to be your personal assistant. Perhaps more, given the very limited lifespan humans have.

You can already ask Google to send a message to your friends, what would be the point of the call? The goal of Duplex is to interface with businesses that are still stuck in a phonecall-only world.

I hope it never gets to, "Ok Google, run Microsoft Support Scam 3 on Victim List 5".

One of the advantages of Google hosting this (as opposed to, say, this technology being an "out in the wild" agglomeration of voice synthesis and machine learning open-source solutions bailing-wired together) is that there's one central authority that can be held accountable.

You're not going to see the described scenario because there's nothing in it for Google, they have full control over both the Google Assistant ecosystem and the set of technologies powering this machine-learning interaction, and they can gate-keep it as much as they want to.

That having been said... If one company can do it, we're only N years out from the tech becoming available "in the wild" as a bailing-wired selection of open-source tools (probably in a Docker image somewhere ;) ).

Even if not another company, people develop actions for Google Assistant so I don't think it's that wild to think that 3rd party Duplex behaviors could be something Google is considering.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com