Hacker News Reader

Comment by vgy7ujm | Hacker News Reader

Yoda makes code more confusing to read at a glance so I would recommend against it.

I don't really see how unless you've never actually read imperative code before; either way you need to read both sides of the comparison to gauge what is being compared. I'm dyslexic and don't write my comparisons that way and still found it easy enough to read those examples at a glance.

But ultimately, even if you do find it harder to parse (for whatever reason(s)) that would only be a training thing. After a few days / weeks of writing your comparisons like that I'm sure you'll find is more jarring to read it the other way around. Like all arguments regarding coding styles, what makes the most difference is simply what you're used to reading and writing rather than actual code layout. (I say this as someone who's programmed in well over a dozen different languages over something like 30 years - you just get used to reading different coding styles after a few weeks of using it)

Consistency is king.

Often when I glance over code to understand what it is doing I don't really care about values. When scanning from left to right it is easier when the left side contains the variable names.

Also I just find it unnatural if I read it out loud. It is called Yoda for a reason.

But again, not of those problems you've described are unteachable. Source code itself doesn't read like how one would structure a paragraph for human consumption. But us programmers learn to parse source code because we read and write it frequently enough to learn to parse it. Just like how one might learn a human language by living and speaking in countries that speak that language.

If you've ever spent more than 5 minutes listening to arguments and counterarguments regarding Python whitespace vs C-style braces - or whether the C-style brace should append your statement for sit on its own line - then you'd quickly see that all these arguments about coding styles are really just personal preference based on what that particular developer is most used to (or pure aesthetics on what looks prettiest - that that's just a different angle of the same debate). Ultimately you were trained to read

    if (variable == value)

and thus equally you can train yourself to read

    if (value == variable)

All the reasons in the world you can't or shouldn't are just excuses to avoid retraining yourself. That's not to say I think everyone should write Yoda-style code - that's purely a matter of personal preference. But my point is arguing your preference as some tangible issue about legibility is dishonest to yourself and every other programmer.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com