Hacker News Reader

Comment by sahillavingia | Hacker News Reader

How long until Google releases a similar thing for YouTube and Justin.tv starts to suffer? :(

Not convinced Google could hurt Justin.tv the way you're imagining; the Justins have too many deals, too much traction.

Can you be more specific here, minus the buzzwords, what "deals" and "traction" does justin.tv have that google/youtube can't hurt them? HN tends to go gaga over YC funded company for no obvious reason and often (but maybe not in this case) rationality and reason goes out of the window.

I agree: http://www.google.com/trends?q=justin.tv%2C+ustream

Their problem is branding. When you think "realtime video streaming online" does the word "justin" even enter your mind?

http://www.google.com/search?q=stream+online - nowhere to be found; http://www.google.com/search?q=video+stream - over halfway down the page

It's quite sad. justin.tv's infrastructure is better than their more popular competitors, but performance doesn't always win the mindshare war.

Agreed. Even after reading this entire article I was unable to locate the app on my iPhone as I was searching for everything except justin.tv

Justin.tv should consider an updated business model where they branch out their video streaming products and rename them to increase comprehension for consumers.

I think the results if you add 'youtube live' to the comparison are interesting.

http://www.google.com/trends?q=justin.tv,+ustream,+youtube+l...

I don't think they'll have much trouble establishing market share once they launch.

Sorry for the buzzwords. What I meant was: there are whole classes of people who are very used to using Justin.tv (and ustream to a lesser extent) for live video. Maybe some of them would switch to Google if YouTube suddenly offered live streaming, but my feeling is that this is a Twitter vs. Google Buzz situation. Google can offer, but if the digerati are already used to another service, they won't necessarily switch.

Justin.tv is kind of a dark horse -- ustream may be better known, but Justin.tv is actually bigger. The Justin guys can probably explain this better than I can. :-)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com