Avocados are wreaking havoc in Mexico | Hacker News Reader

Avocados are wreaking havoc in Mexico

bleisure-travel.net

29 pointsvelmu13 comments

Headline should be "The drug cartels are wreaking havoc in Mexico". They would be trying to extract rent from any industry, the industry just happens to be avocados.

From the article, expanding avocado farms is leading to drought and deforestation. Increased use of pesticides is making the pickers sick and poisoning the ground water

So buy organic or fair trade avocados instead?

Or, even better, don't buy food that has to get transported thousands of miles. Stick to local and seasonal cuisine. That is also the most pro-environmental option.

In today's world local cuisine is not better for the environment. It's worse. Transportation costs are extremely minimal but fertilizer and other growing costs are way higher. Using only local cuisine is actually worse for the environment than using food that grew in the best place possible for it.

This is false. Local food is generally more expensive because real estate and labor costs are way higher. Nutrients and electricity (the inputs with direct environmental impact) account for a tiny fraction of the cost of production.

Yields may be slightly lower, but farmers won't grow crops that aren't relatively optimized to the environment. No one's growing avocados in Missouri (except perhaps in a tropical greenhouse, which likely is designed to self-sufficiently sustain its environment).

in this case, drug cartels extracting rent from them would be a boon to the environment, since it is now less profitable to grow avocados.

on the contrary, drug cartels jumped at this opportunity to increase profits by effectively controlling price, reaching ridiculous levels down there

I'm always wary of articles that have zero numbers in them.

This article is pretty weak. It’s just a haphazard jumble of “drug gangs extort money from avocado farmers” and “agriculture has potentially harmful impacts on the environment” with no attempt to quantify, dig deeper, or present evidence about any of its claims. The seed of a good story is here, just no effort to perform novel reporting.

Anyone have a major news source for similar information? This site has no sources, citations, no byline, nothing at all.

https://www.proceso.com.mx/503719/productores-denuncian-crim... drug cartels becoming MITM and buying land and whole crops, in cash

this whole website is bizarre, running a whois shows the owner as joker.com

Reply on news.ycombinator.com