Would I prefer a world where men didn't have to waste their health in mines and women theirs in prostitution? Sure, I'm all for a UBI. But it is hypocrisy to treat these professions and the health implications they have as any different.
Sexual intercourse is as much a necessity as is mining. More so, I'd say. Humans are not mining machines, they are reproduction machines. To deny this is to deny human nature. Also, sex in and in itself has nothing to do with respect or disrespect. It's simply a physical act.
All these things you'd have. With of without prostitution. These are issues of the human condition, not something that can be magicked away by prohibiting the act of sexual intercourse for economic benefits. It just doesn't work. There have been many moral and religious campaigns to make prostitution illegal. And still we have broken families, STDs, domestic violence, child abuse, etc.
As for the dehumanizing effect of sexual intercourse; you might be on to something. But sex is a strange thing that cannot really be understood by thinking very hard about it. So; some very independent women like to be degraded during sex, so do some men. This is just part of the spectrum. As long as everybody involved consents, I don't see the problem.
And yes, brokeness will be with us for all time. So, your solution is to just allow things to get worse? Sometimes you have to take a hard stand on things to help people not destroy themselves.
To imply that all social norms and taboos are moot in the face of individuality is to imply that the individual is the core atom of humanity and it clearly is not -- it is the family.
That doesn't make them absolute.
As for sex as entertainment; yes, sexual intercourse in all its wonderful varieties is entertainment. Just look at some of our closest cousins, the Bonobos. They entertain themselves all day long with sex. Well, almost.
I really don't get why you think that sex is something bad. I think it's wonderful and we should have much more of it. - it's just way better entertainment then war.
Are you saying that they don't need sex at all and should go without? Because that's a pretty puritanical viewpoint that hasn't been backed up by any sort of history.
Additionally "need" can be pretty subjective. People's sex drives are some thing they are born with. We don't "need" rare earth metals to have shiny electronics so why is it ok to have people forced into mining by it being their only choice economically?
My opinion is based largely on the fact that there are plenty of women who want to do this, or particularly enjoy it, as well as the unfortunate cases of people who feel they have no other choice. In either of those cases, punishing the people who are in this industry is wrong.
They are not protected by regulations, they don't receive pensions and they don't pay taxes.
There are a lot of jobs that might not be the best life choices. But that's no reason to make it illegal and force the people performing these jobs underground.
It sounds like you just have a problem with sex in general and protecting women is about as much a goal of yours as when politicians cry "think of the children"
But yes, I am sure people generally agree that the women who don't want to be sex workers should have other options (or be made aware of options).
And how far can society go when dictating what a person can or can not do? People are allowed to smoke and drink. People have sex without payments happening too.
As long as we force people to do unpleasant and potentially harmful jobs for a living, I don't see any reason to differentiate between oil-rig workers and prostitutes.
By making it legal, prostitutes enjoy legal protection, health and social benefits. What's not to like?
Prostitution is both unnecessary and destructive to all parties involved.
Clear difference between the two categories.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_among_animals
I guess it's not coal mining...
There are no objective truths in all of the moralizing anti-prostitution comments you're making in this thread. All of the virtues you're playing up are nothing more than your personal beliefs. Your read on history is selective and has been called out repeatedly for emphasizing the things you want to see while ignoring the facts you don't.
Life is essentially suicide in that aspect. Sex workers have the option to use condoms. There are tests, and most STDs are not lethal.
Abuse is being enabled by making the business hide in shadows.
edit: to who i was replying to the reply button was gone.