When I'm on-call and get an alarm on a server, checking that colleagues aren't logged in is normally the first thing you do. If a service fails it's more often than not someone doing maintenance, and they just forgot to tell you, or disable monitoring. And as someone else pointed out, also check disk usage.
Hacker News can be a little blind to the fact that most software projects are rather small and modern servers are really powerful. It's actually pretty rare that someone manages enough infrastructure for a single service that logging isn't a viable option.