Github is totally within their right to hold this close to their vest for whatever reason, I don't see the big deal with it.

Where does the line get drawn the OP asks? I'm unsure, but I believe in Github to make a smart call there. Not every situation is a slippery slope to facism / dictatorships, and I'm unsure why many things nowadays are described with this sort of notion attached to them.

Definitely feel like I wasted time reading this whole thing, and now wasted time posting, and now I'm sad.