Hacker News Reader

Comment by georgeecollins | Hacker News Reader

We may not be able to defend Taiwan, but for only $1.07t we have "won" Afghanistan.* /s

*https://www.thebalance.com/cost-of-afghanistan-war-timeline-...

Defending Taiwan (and Japan) is one area where the US would do exceptionally well in any war. They have no rival on the sea (which is why they are continuously able to conduct their 'freedom of navigation' exercises right on Chinas door step).

Conversely, any land war in North Korea I feel would end disastrously for them - as it arguably did the first time around.

> They have no rival on the sea

Well other than the 'carrier killer' missiles like the DF-21D.

Today, probably yes for Taiwan, certainly yes for Japan. But the pace at which the Chinese Air Force is improving you have to wonder if they could eventually develop air superiority over the South China Sea and prevent US surface ships from getting too close. If so, would the Taiwanese fight bitterly, or would they give in? Fifteen years ago a scenario like that seemed like a fantasy. 'And Afghanistan was a mess.

Also, the British didn't have a rival in the North Sea when the Germans conquered Norway.

> Defending Taiwan (and Japan) is one area where the US would do exceptionally well in any war.

According to a former US State department official (I heard on a recent podcast interview), China never cared to take Taiwan. If they wanted to, all they need to do is cut off access to fresh water from the Chinese mainland.

The US might be able to prevent a ground invasion or counter-attack missile batteries, but the island will fall quickly if China put it's mind to the task.

No, that must be Hong Kong. Taiwan is an island and not connected to the mainland.

Nice website, note by the same source that the US military budget is about $1t per year ($886 billion). Even more insane.

https://www.thebalance.com/u-s-military-budget-components-ch...

For a fraction of that I'm pretty sure we could be well under way of self-sustaining colonization of other Solar System bodies.

Imagine what could have happened had we awarded $10,000 to 100,000,000 American citizens instead, or $100,000 to only 10,000,000, or ... You get the idea.

Oh but we did award that money to American citizens, it's just wasn't as balanced as your numbers.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com