Hacker News Reader

Comment by usrusr | Hacker News Reader

If car horns were only half as loud to the honking driver, protected in his glass cage, as they are to a person standing unprotected next to the car, honking would not be much of an issue...

View on HN

The effect is also worse because you're not expecting it, whereas the driver is.

There are some problems in life where a punch in the mouth seems like the only viable solution.

I think this is mainly an enforcement and punishment issue. I don't know the situation in other countries, but here in Germany you are only allowed to honk if there's a danger. Enforcing this rule with a hard penalty (500+ Euros or something like that) would do wonders to cure people of their "I will honk in every damn situation" mentality.

In the UK the law is similar but not enforced, I don't think the penalty is that great either?

Comparing it to talking/texting on a mobile phone while driving, where the penalties are moderate and there is some enforcement, attitudes are changing - very slowly though.

In the US, this varies per state. In most states, though, it is illegal to "unnecessarily" honk your horn. But as the sibling commented about the UK, it's rarely enforced and is at the discretion of the officer.

I don't think most people know it is illegal.

I would worry about unintended second-order effects of that. If there is a danger, I do want a driver to honk quickly and without hesitation. Might imposing an external after-the-fact judgement on whether it was neccesary or not, with a very stiff fine, cause people to hesitate in situations where they shouldn't?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com