This is such a classic troll. Not even a subtle new variant, but practically a 1980s Usenet troll. I was going to ask if people minded if I killed it, but a forum just can't let itself be pwned by trolls this blatant. So...
It's provocative, but gets to an issue at the core of YC and HN. If you lead with the quality of your ideas, which I believe that you do, then it's a useful conversation.