Multiple issue and pull request templates | Hacker News Reader

Multiple issue and pull request templates

github.com

17 pointsclarkbw7 comments

interesting to see GitHub catching up to features in GitLab...

https://gitlab.com/help/user/project/description_templates.m...

;)

They should definitely consider an extra <select> field for the generic one, with the names of the issue types on then. And one pre-selected when going from a specific one.

How to change from bug issue template to normal issue template or for feature request? Changing the URL manually is not going to cut it, and the interface looks like the generic one for issues so users would expect going back to issues => new is going to be the same.

IMHO this could have been so good and useful, but they messed up the implementation details...

Note/Edit: I didn't look at Gitlab's implementation before comenting this, but now that I saw it that is exactly what I imagined/described here!

A switcher is under consideration but we're focused on some other (what we believe are) more important aspects right now and wanted to get this part out the door quickly for people to start using.

I wouldn't consider a switcher implementation details as much as another user flow.

Since you bring it up I wonder how often users find that switcher and "do the right thing" in GitLab. I would expect that number is pretty low and instead users submit with the template they arrived on. As in I would assume the feature is likely useful for advanced users to more easily switch (certainly good there) but I'm skeptical that new users would look to use this. What do you think?

Great! It'd be useful to automatically apply a label (e.g "bug") for a certain issue template.

Default: /ISSUE_TEMPLATE.md

/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/<name>.md

Default: /PULL_REQUEST_TEMPLATE.md

/PULL_REQUEST_TEMPLATE/<name>.md

You can leave the last S for off (for savings) if you want /ISSUE_TEMPLATE(S)/ or /PULL_REQUEST_TEMPLATE(S)/

Good call. I've updated the post.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com