Hacker News Reader

Would you sign a contract which can be arbitrarily changed by a third party at any point? Would you signed a contact where the terms are not clearly defined? This is the state of marriage today in many Western countries

View on HN

1. The terms are clearly defined in legislation 2. Do you refuse to drive a car for the same reason?

1. It depends on your jurisdiction. Often they are not clearly defined. In part because there are so many possibilities and it's difficult to write rules to handle all of them. This is where judges come in. If you go to court, it will depend on the judge and their take on the situation.

That aside, my original point stands. You sign a marriage contract and the state legislature can change the terms of the contract without your consent.

2. Could you elaborate? I couldn't understand the point you made. As far as I'm aware you don't sign a contract when you drive a car.

I would not.

Did you mean to reply to parent comment ?

Maybe I could have been more clear. I agree with you and was echoing your sentiment with a couple of questions to back up your point.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com