Well, your comment seemed a nitpicky objecting-to-everything-they-said, and tiresomely missing the point at every turn. From the initial pedantic "Please distinguish proof and evidence." Do you talk to your friends like that? It's already headmasterish and snarky. It's not clear what you're asking for. But you move on after 5 words to dispatch the next offending sentence, like they're a succession of pesky bad guys in a kung fu movie waiting to be swatted down by our hero.

I don't think the comment you were replying to was a model of clarity; the quote is a paraphrase of a paraphrase of an argument in James' The Will To Believe. I'm familiar with that essay (not one of his most impressive) so maybe it was easier for me to hear what they were trying to say. But "WTF?!" etc isn't helpful. ... Objecting to every sentence like that doesn't even begin to address what they were trying to say. Anyway, all of this seems obvious, I think you know this, I'll stop here. Your comment read like you didn't care about what they were trying to say, just to knock them out of the water with any available weapon, which you seem to think you had done.