Hacker News Reader

Comment by bogomipz | Hacker News Reader

Indonesia actually has a larger GDP than the Netherlands and the largest economy in South East Asia

GDP per capita is more than 4x in Netherlands (on a PPP basis). On a straight per capita basis, it’s even higher. See, e.g., https://tradingeconomics.com/indonesia/gdp-per-capita

Lower GDP generally also means infrastructure works are cheaper.

Also, the problem here mostly seems to be not money, but government. As the article states “Nobody here believes in the greater good […] There is no trust”. Short-term, how much more expensive would it be to get clean water from the rivers flowing into Jakarta, instead of from those illegal wells?

Purchasing Power Parity is meant to capture elements like cheaper costs of construction. It gives a real sense of the gap between Indonesia (4th most populous country, with China and India neck-and-neck, followed quite a bit lower by the U.S.) and the Netherlands. Corruption may be a factor too, but you can’t squeeze blood from a stone.

Is meant to, yes, but it doesn’t, because it isn’t possible to capture pricing differences in a single number. In general, cheap to transport durable goods (such as electronics) move easily between countries and, hence, are priced similarly (barring taxes and import tariffs).

Less cheap to transport (e.g. bricks) or less durable (e.g. fruit) goods move less easily, and labor moves least easily.

Consequently, it is way cheaper in poorer countries to have personnel, to pay people for repairing stuff, etc.

Huh? That source gives Indonesia about USD4000 and for Netherlands around USD52000 per capita.

(I think I misread your comment and others might too, so I'm leaving this here)

With 300 million people compared to 18 million in Netherlands, I'm not sure it's worth mentioning.

But if your point is that Indonesia is not to be overlooked, then that is quite true.

My point was a response to the parent comment:

>"Sadly Indonesia doesn't have the near limitless resources of its old colonial owner that keeps Amsterdam/Holland from sinking"

When in fact fact it does have the resources to build a Delta Works-like system similar to the Netherlands.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com