Hacker News Reader

Anyone know if they are MVCC based? ACID? Mobile site is Spartan on details.

EDIT: They do mention it's not transactional.

Not transactional in what way?

Their "Limitations" doc doesn't mention that it lacks transactions (https://github.com/facebook/mysql-5.6/wiki/MyRocks-limitatio...). They have a "Transaction Isolation" doc that describes some options and differences (https://github.com/facebook/mysql-5.6/wiki/Transaction-Isola...).

Perhaps I misunderstood:

"Using mixed storage engines is not recommended in production because it is not really transactional, ..."

http://myrocks.io/docs/getting-started/#migrating-from-innod...

I believe that is saying that MySQL transactions across two storage engines are not transactional, as that would require two-phase-commit (2PC) or similar. It might also have implications for replication.

MyRocks itself definitely has transactions. As the wiki explains, it uses snapshots (MVCC) for transaction isolation.

MySQL does have a system for two phase commit. I've seen it accidentally triggered on a system that executed queries that joined two different engines (InnoDB and TokuDB) and had the binlog turned off. It's called XA mode and it requires an fsync per commit to a transaction log file.

Where do they say it's not transactional?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com