Comment by frik | Hacker News Reader

Comment by frik | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Is KDE back to KDE3 functionality? If so I will give it another try. But KDE4.x was sooo bad, it was a complete rewrite and every single decision was ill-advised. In retrospective it almost looks like someone had great fun running both KDE and Gnome to the ground and keep users away from Linux desktop. I mean KDE3 and Gnome2 were good, almost perfect. KDE was more Windows alike and had ton of settings to adjust things. Gnome 2 was more MacOS alike and more opinionated with little settings. When KDE4 tanked, I switched to Gnome 2. When Gnome 3 tanked I switched to Ubuntu with Unity. Now Ubuntu 17 tanked with its shitty Gnome 3 where Terminal app has no tab-support and Gnome Texteditor is a weird zombie that lost most of the Gnome3 Texteditor functionality and toolbars. I hope Ubuntu 18 LTS comes with some reasonable improvements to Gnome 3, or I will look elsewhere.

KDE 4 was the biggest disappointment I had in the Linux world. It became usable to me a few years later.

KDE 5 is fine, doing a few changes like disabling plasma volume and starting KMix at startup instead. Still have to use pavucontrol occasionally, though.

Yesterday I discovered you can switch the menu style (right click -> alternatives) to a more classic type (like KDE 3, plus favorites), or to a full screen win8 type (for tablets).

You can also download Simple Menu [1] and Tiled Menu [2] with a right-click on the panel, then Add Widgets -> Get New Widgets.

I think, they'll be available in that Alternatives-menu then. If not, you can add them through Add Widgets.

Plasma treats everything as either a widget(/"Plasmoid") or as a panel. So, you also have to have your widgets unlocked for all of this to work (including the Alternatives-menu).

[1]: https://store.kde.org/p/1169537/ [2]: https://store.kde.org/p/1160672

Simple Menu looks really neat. Thanks!

KDE 4 was on par with KDE 3 since about the 4.4 or 4.5 release, a few years ago. I too was a KDE 3, then Trinity, holdout.

KDE 5, last I tried, was still missing some features and had troubles with panel positioning on multi-monitor setups. It is also missing all the little touches that made KDE 3/4 so pleasant to work with, such as Ctrl-U to clear a field (lifted right from Emacs). I stick with KDE 4 on CentOS.

Ctrl-U works, just tried it.

Thanks, I haven't tried KDE 5 in over a year. I might give it another look.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com