Hacker News Reader

Those are nations, not civilizations. Civilization in the 20th century and some significant time before that was global and ever increasingly so.

The USSR and British "collapse" were the loss of empires, not a collapse of civilization. The systems of society were shuffled but not destroyed.

View on HN

They had as much (or rather as little) to do with ‘nations’ as the Roman Empire. Vast conquered areas, spanning several religions, languages, and etnicities.

The commonwealth was a civilization as much as the roman empire were.

The Commonwealth, as a civilization, still exists unchanged. Unless the Australians actually have lost the skill of writing and reverted to their previous tribal structures.

The commonwealth is nowhere where it used to be and Britannia do not rule the world like they did.

It's a perfect example of the fall of an empire and civilization without any collapse.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com