Comparing diets like this is stupid. The optimal diet is different for everyone. Lean, active people tend to do better with a high carbohydrate diet, while sedentary, overweight people tend to do better on high fat diets. Furthermore, an individual's microbiome and genetics make even these broad generalizations frequently inaccurate. For example, eggs are a critical part of my diet, but for some people they're a terrible idea.
Pretty much the only thing that is common among everyone is that a high fermentable carbohydrate intake (e.g. legumes) is extremely healthy.