Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by narrowtux | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

narrowtux

I don't know. If you run those on a laptop you pretty much kill battery life, same thing with phones.

View on HN

If HTML5's battery API ever became a thing, this issue could be solved without any user interaction.

Can you elaborate how?

"is this user on a mobile device or laptop? Don't mine."

Meh, then you're back to the same dilemma ads have: you have to convince the users to visit your page from a desktop PC as much as possible. And that usually means making the mobile experience as bad as possible. Which the users won't like for fairly obvious reasons.

Why would a miner want to implement that?

So that people don't get angry?

Pretty sure user anger didn't stop the prevalence of pop-up Punch The Monkey adverts. The massive rise in adblocking forced the ad industry to stop being quite so obnoxious.

So, yeah, relying on advertisers to not piss off users is a bit much given their business model relies on interrupting your attention.

No, not even that.

More like: "Is this user's battery below 50% and discharging? If not, he'll probably not even notice this."

Then users would just set their machine to say they're on a slow laptop with 1% battery left.

I would not expect miners to voluntarily stop mining just because the user agent reports low battery. Any miners that care about mobile users could check the user agent string and throttle mining.

If the battery API ever becomes a thing, the first thing I will do is to hack the browser to perpetually report an almost-dying battery. Similarly, if there ever comes a standard for network link quality, I'll make my browser report I'm on a 56k modem.

The reason is simple: whatever cruft the site decides to only serve to high-end users is the cruft I'm very much not interested in seeing.

And because I'm definitely not alone in this thinking, those APIs will be failures for anything other than getting additional bits for tracking and profiling people.

It'd be fine. You would do that, I would do that and most people here would do that. The vast majority of users would not, it's just like adblockers: only a minority uses them.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com