Ask HN: Would it be legal if I put my web scraping scripts (lib) on GitHub? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Would it be legal if I put my web scraping scripts (lib) on GitHub?

9 points__julia__7 comments

Hi, I am using the data for research purposes. How bad it is to show scrappers in my Github account. I am using scrappers to collect data from news sources, analyze them and work on some data analysis tools (recommendation sys, data visualization of aggregated data, .. etc).

I tried to consult with some other people in the field, but most of them gave mixed signals, and recommended articles like [1](https://gijn.org/2015/08/12/on-the-ethics-of-web-scraping-and-data-journalism/).

As far as I know, some big companies like BBC do have some scrapping tools like [Juicer](http://bbcnewslabs.co.uk/projects/juicer/). Any one of you got into troubles by putting such scripts publicly.

Best,

I wouldn't worry about it, as long as the code is general enough. E.g if it is obvious that the code is about scraping a specific site's stock tickers and that it disregards the site policy and robots.txt, I would think twice about publishing it. Otherwise not. Note that some European countries have much more strict laws wrt scraping than the US has.

As long as you obey robots.txt there is nothing wrong with crawling. Your code in GitHub doesn't give any indication of what sites you collect data from so there is no indication that you are scraping instead of using it to crawl in an acceptable manner. Though it wouldn't hurt to label your work as crawler scripts instead of scraping scripts ;)

Why use your own scripts and not Nutch?

Do you know about Common Crawl? https://aws.amazon.com/public-datasets/common-crawl/ It obeys robots.txt so it may not have everything you want, but it could save you part of the effort of crawling yourself.

The word you want is "scrapers". Whereas "scrappers" are people who are good at fighting.

This has to be the no. 1 misspelling I see online among developers.

A scrapper is UK colloquial for an old car in bad nick.

Oh and "nick" is UK colloquial for condition. Also can mean jail. And also can mean to steal.

maybe a relative of "paddock basher"

I am building something along those lines so always interested to see which sources / methods are used - any public links?

I removed the project.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com