Tell HN: HN is now blocked by UAE proxy | Hacker News Reader

Tell HN: HN is now blocked by UAE proxy

47 pointsphugoid18 comments

I noticed yesterday that HN is now blocked by Etisalat, one of the United Arab Emirates' two telecom companies. Their proxy server displays a page like this instead: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Block_etisalat_3.jpg

Sites usually get blocked because a customer complained to Etisalat about their content, or because they were arbitrarily added to the SmartFilter database. I think it's the latter in this case.

I will follow up with Etisalat and let you know if I make any progress...

View on HN

After reading this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etisalat#Internet_Censorship

I'm forced to conclude we all must be doing something right.

If you take a moment to pause the "ra ra shish koom ba" cheerleading, it's worth contemplating what manner of content this site would have that would've caused this.

"Websites criticizing the United Arab Emirates"

I think this is about to become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Does http://apps.ycombinator.com/ work?

Yes it does from inside the UAE. Thanks for the hint.

I think it's added to SmartFilter, I noticed that news.ycombinator.com was blocked at work yesterday. news.ycombinator.net works though.

Not very smart then, eh?

you can also use news.ycombinator.org

I noticed this yesterday at work (who use Etisalat). I emailed then, trying to explain the usual content of HN.

Back at home though (on Du), it's not blocked.

I suspect it is just an automatic block, but we'll see.

in the non-english nanny state you really wonder how HACKER news got b& when most americans conflate hacker/cracker?

I think you'll hit a wall pretty quick. Some bureaucrat saw hacker or maybe even realized there IS disruptive info here and ban it went.

Either that or it's a clever move to make the country more productive.

I get a little bit more scared each time I hear this type of story. Is there any hope for clever technology which makes it impossible to intelligently filter traffic? Some sort of mesh networking something? Surely someone on HN must know the state of the art here.

Just proxy/VPN out.

https is a good way to get around the block. Unfortunately https on HN redirects to http.

edit:

@andrewtj : yes, http://apps.ycombinator.com works.

I liked their old image better: http://widgetsex.com/uae.png

(disregard what looks like an NSFW domain, it's just a URL I bought on a whim. If you take off the image, you'll see my friend's dog, widget, winking at you in a suggestive-but-entirely-SFW manner.)

Any HN users want to do a meetup in Dubai? My email is in my profile.

Only the future will tell if there Non-Smart automatic filters have detected it, or their Smart-Non-automatic filters.

also, http://hackerne.ws would still work, I guess.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com