Hacker News Reader

Comment by dragonwriter | Hacker News Reader

> If you don't build roads, people will still come. Instead of having more roads = more cars you end up with same road = more cars, which is not ideal.

That's empirically not as true as it intuitively seems; induced traffic is a thing.

> Personally, I think California's HSR project is stupid and the money could be better spent on regional light rail plus conventional rail between metro areas.

But, the HSR project is spending money on regional light rail and conventional rail between metro areas.

View on HN

>That's empirically not as true as it intuitively seems; induced traffic is a thing.

It's definitely empirically true. I've watched it happen for decades. There are certainly new cars on the road, but they would have been there anyway, for the most part. If you have a growing economy people immigrate in search of jobs whether the infrastructure is ready or not.

Now, I'd rather we had enough rail to handle all those people and more, but the problem with rail is before your network is built out completely it's not very useful.

>But, the HSR project is spending money on regional light rail and conventional rail between metro areas.

Great. Then all we need to cancel is the HSR itself.

It's definitely empirically true, and you've got a vague anecdote to prove it.

My "vague anecdote" is California has more than twice the population it had in 1970. That's not a question of induced driving. That's running to stay even.

> It's definitely empirically true. I've watched it happen for decades. There are certainly new cars on the road, but they would have been there anyway, for the most part.

Your unsupported speculation of what you expect would have been true in a counterfactual situation is not support for a claim of empirical truth.

> If you have a growing economy people immigrate in search of jobs whether the infrastructure is ready or not.

People are not the same thing as the car trips; whether the same number of people would have been present with less road capacity is a different question than whether the number of car trips would have been.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com