Hacker News Reader

Comment by turnspike | Hacker News Reader

- The story of the world is largely a military history. For brutal facts, figures and movements and minimum pathos: http://strategypage.com

- Dan Carlin's Common Sense podcast is a relatively unbiased source for US politics.

View on HN

I believe I tried dan Carlin but was turned off when he made the argument that a third party vote is a wasted vote.

In what way is it not? I'm a firm believer that the two-party system sucks and we need electoral reform to make third parties viable, and every time I vote I wish it were already so... but there's no escaping the reality that the system, as it is built today, makes third-party votes as useful as drawing a spaceship on your ballot.

BECAUSE people believe that. If everyone who wanted to vote third party actually voted third party, they’d actually stand a chance.

Because the nature of the system makes it unstable with more than two viable parties. It is possible for a third party to attain a critical mass and become viable, but it would displace one of the current major parties and we'd be back to a two-party system.

You probably caught him at a bad time. He's also argued that third parties are the only way forward in America (which I think is not true). At this point, his Common Sense podcast is somewhat repetitive of his previous stuff, but he's trying to say new things each time, which is tough.

His Hardcore History stuff, on the other hand, is mind-blowingly awesome!!! And not repetitive.

convincing someone to waste their vote is a powerful tool.

Dan's saying that the political machine is so rigged that it's very difficult for a third party to succeed. He gets right down into the gory details of the electoral system, it's eye opening.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com