Pretty fantastic. The paper is thick and the ink doesn't come off on your hands. It feels a little bit like a collectors item, at least for geeks like me.

His simple design aesthetic is so good that my other magazines feel jarring and cluttered. It feels like how a magazine should be.

See this thread on issue 1, where several people comment on the quality: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1394526

Specifically, this comment is pretty representative: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1394730

I bought issue #1, and I was moderately impressed -- it did feel like a magazine, but not quite at the professional level. Almost, though. I was quite happy with it and I am buying this one too.