Hacker News Reader

Comment by btbytes | Hacker News Reader

Same with Tamil, Kannada, Bengali, Malayalam etc.,

Tamil is a classical language like greek, hebrew, chinese etc. Its much older than telugu and the other Indian languages. Malayalam and kanada is derived from tamil

Malayalam diverged from Tamil. But, Kannada is not a derivative of tamil.

Of course Kannada evolved from ancient Tamil. If you know both the languages, you can easily find root words for most current day Kannada words in ancient Tamil sangam poetry (like ooru=>oor referring to town, kaaveri=>kaaviri, etc.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dravidian_languages

Kannada, Telugu, Malayalam all have higher degrees of impact due to Sanskrit but they are all dravidian languages, derived from ancient Tamil.

Your Wikipedia link disagrees that all of the Dravidian languages are derived from ancient Tamil. It describes them as common descendents of Proto-Dravidian. It cites the attested literature of Tamil as being 2,000 years old.

Calling Tamil much older than Telugu is probably not appropriate. They both developed during the same time.

Modern-day Greek, Hebrew, and Chinese are all very different from their "classical" versions.

The Tamil language currently used is not same as the one when the other Dravidian languages separated, So calling other languages 'derived' from the Tamil is not correct. All Dravidian languages have same root, so calling it 'Dravidian Language' and Tamil, Kannada, Malayalam & Telugu etc. derived from that language is more accurate and avoids the confusion

> an enormous literary corpus reaching back to before English even existed

Certainly true of Telegu, Tamil, Kannada, and Malayalam. But because Bengali is, like English, an Indo-European language, not true of it. Also, not sure what you mean by "etc".

Sanskrit is also Indo-European, and definitely had a large literary corpus before English became separate from Old Norse.

Let the regional language wars begin.

Aren't most wars about regional languages, when you get down to the nuts and bolts?

English is less than 1,000 years old in its identifiably modern form.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com