Hacker News Reader

Comment by gregwtmtno | Hacker News Reader

Though it should be noted that Quebec has much stricter immigration rules than most of Canada.

To elaborate, Quebec has additional requirements to verify your ability to integrate into society. Here's an article that explains some of the differences:

http://correresmidestino.com/immigrating-to-quebec-still-wor...

View on HN

Can you explain this?

I'm Canadian and unless I'm missing something, or just really don't understand our immigration policies, once you are in Canada you can move where ever you want.

I mean provinces, including Quebec, should have absolutely zero say as to if you can live in them once you are in Canada.

Once you get permanent citizenship, yes. However that takes a couple of years to obtain, and meanwhile there are pretty severe requirements.

(I know a few people who have immigrated but I have no direct experience with specific policies)

Permanent residency*, which is a lot quicker to get than citizenship.

It's been a long time since I looked at this, but IIRC under some visas the federal system gives you extra points for selecting certain provinces. The rationale is that otherwise every immigrant will choose Toronto or Vancouver. Under those visas, you have to be resident in the province you picked for a certain amount of time (again IIRC I think is was 1 year) as a condition of your visa. Quebec is one of the provinces where you can get extra points to get in, but only if you satisfy the Quebec requirements (which generally means French language skill or agreeing to take French language classes, I think).

Disclaimer: when I say it's been a long time since I looked at this, I'm talking 20 years or so. Things have probably changed (or I have misremembered). But it gives you some idea anyway. In my recollection, if you choose not to get extra points for selecting special regions to settle in, then you can settle anywhere you like. Programmers, doctors, nurses etc almost never need the extra points, so it's kind of moot in this discussion.

I don't know but suspect this is no longer the case, Quebec still offers the ability to more or less buy citizenship, even though the federal program was shut down. All you have to do is say you "intend to" settle in Quebec (wink wink) - they get the financial benefits, and the majority of the participants immediately move to Toronto or Vancouver, typically buying a few houses upon arrival as a store of cash. Of course, this is all "speculation", as the Canadian government deems the statistics on this sort of thing to be none of the business of citizens, who are the ones who experience the positive or negative consequences.

http://www.investorimmigrationcanada.com/

But provinces can sponsor people for immigration. I heard that Quebec is an easy way into Canada for French speakers, even if they don't want to live in Quebec.

You mostly just need the additional CSQ form to fill.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com