Hacker News Reader

Comment by walterstucco | Hacker News Reader

Meanwhile men can tell the same stories of harassment, under payment and stalled careers but nobody cares because, you know, they kinda deserve it for being men.

I won't deny there is a problem in the valley, that's why I stayed in Europe, but the narrative men Vs women is wrong, US media should explore the fact that the whole American dream is about being abusive.

    Hypocrisy! Brutality! The elite! 
    All of which are American dreams! 
    -- RATM

View on HN

This is a terrible HN comment that manages to combine gender flamebait with nationalistic flamebait. If you post like this again, we will ban you.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

Edit: Ok you guys, point taken, s/insults/flamebait/. Late-night misstep!

What gender insult?

It is not insulting any gender. Also I think your bar for a "nationalistic insult" is a little low - all countries are open to criticism.

You're right, "insults" was the wrong word. A better word is "flamebait". The last thing we need here is more drive-by gender flamewarrage, and when accounts do this repeatedly (as this one has), we ban them. Hence the warning.

> drive-by gender flamewarrage

if you haven't noticed, that was my point

it's no gender war

it's a cultural problem, competition taken to extremes can't end well

What are you talking about?

Where exactly is the insult..? I can imagine it's politically sensitive to people from the US, but that's not forbidden here as far as I know. It's not even rude.

Unless the original comment has been changed this is a strange thing to say.

The US has far less work benefits and rights than most first world nation's. Not saying I agree with OP but it's a valid theory that silicon valley being in the US might make it more hostile to all workers.

I love how greyed-out this comment is. When your moderation is deficient, the meta-moderation of HN has accomodated.

This is 1 of maybe 4 instances I've seen your moderation be 100% off, but I'm glad it didn't go unchecked.

If you can find the other ones for me, I'd appreciate knowing what they are. Maybe email them to hn@ycombinator.com?

it's the lyrics from a rage against the machine's song…

an american band

> edit: Ok you guys, s/insults/flamebait/ above. Late night moderation slip on my part!

an "I am sorry" would have sufficed

I've made no flamebait nor insulted anyone or any country

I've just said don't make this "men VS women" because it's powerful men and women chasing the "american dream" abusing of less powerful men and women that are trying to make a living

The only flamebait here was your comment

Actually you've done this flamebait thing repeatedly:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14534396

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14534306

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14506129

This is not at all what HN is for. Such comments amount to trolling whether you intend to or not. We have enough trouble with flamewars already without people casually flinging lit matches into parched forests.

We've warned you twice now. If you don't change your comments to adhere to the community guidelines (i.e. to post civilly and substantively, or not at all), we will assume you don't want to use the site as intended and ban you. If you do want to use the site as intended, please (re)-read the following:

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

I agree that walterstucco's comments on such a topic are unsunstanciaive and overly dismissive.

However, I think that last comment should be taken in context with what it is replying to. Maybe a rule should be added to the guidelines:

"If you flag or downvote a comment for being uncivil, do not reply to it in kind"

> "Edit: Ok you guys, point taken, s/insults/flamebait/ above. Late-night misstep!"

Perhaps you should calm down a bit instead of constantly policing HN for thought-crime.

There is a difference between moderating and constantly shutting down everyone that doesn't agree with your strict views of the world (i.e. what you've just did) while giving a stage to the ones that propagate your ideology (i.e. those flags you keep removing from opinionated and non factual posts).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com