Hacker News Reader

Comment by eridius | Hacker News Reader

The app store guidelines very clearly prohibit what you tried to do, and it's been well-known that this is prohibited for many many years.

If you want to be able to get new users with your app, you need to provide an IAP subscription option.

View on HN

I was rejected for linking to a THIRD PARTY service that happened to have a paid plan too. Didn't get any revenue from that and couldn't very well offer IAPs even if I wanted to... after being in the store for a year, too. The reviewers are grossly incompetent more often than not.

Doesn't Netflix's app's first screen say sign in or visit Netflix.com to sign up?

I'd imagine there's some companies that even Apple can't bully.

They used to do that, and that is ok. But you can't link them to an external site to pay and sign up.

But now they just bit the bullet and give up a portion of their revenue to Apple and Google. Although I believe 30% is only for the first year. It goes down after that.

But, if you have existing customers and their account has lapsed and must be paid to re-enable service your app can link to a web-page payment form

I suspect a big player like Netflix can negotiate the revenue split with Apple. Nothing we mere mortals can.

The weird thing is why would Apple get any of the revenue. I don't think microsoft gets any from people that watch netflix in their browser, nor google if people watch it in chrome.

In theory either could interfere with your interaction with netflix and demand money to allow it through. Google could start a whitelist of good sites and demand revenue sharing to be allowed on the list but people would go ballistic and firefox would have a lot more users.

I really don't see how apples arrangement is any more acceptable.

What your describing is more like what ISPs will do without net neutrality. Browsers have financial incentives not to do that (e.g. there are well know free alternatives, and it's an important feature of android or windows that you can browse the internet).

Holy shit. I searched this and found [1]. 15% recurring revenue per signup seems like one hell of a commission. But perhaps warranted if it's bringing in people that haven't had Netflix before and legitimately sign up via the app.

1: https://www.macrumors.com/2015/04/13/apple-15-percent-cut-ap...

I don't think they can. Netflix needs Apple more than Apple needs Netflix.

You can get new users through your app, you just have to provide a free version. Then if they want to use the premium features, they can log in on the web and pay. But you can't link them to the site or to an external payment method.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com