Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by Kipters | Hacker News Reader

Full thread

Kipters·

At first I was excited, but then I read the docs:

> Read only

> Only supports NDEF formatted tags

> Available only on iPhone 7 and newer

Basically, this is even more crippled than what WP 8.0 did five years ago (and back then I thought it was too crippled to be useful)

View on HN

I wonder if there is any technical reason for requiring iPhone 7. I thought iPhone 6 and iPhone 6s also had some kind of NFC hardware present to support Apple Pay.

IIRC, because the payment terminals have their own power source, previous iPhone generations lacked the induction coils necessary to support passive NFC tags. Presumably they were added to the iPhone 7?

It could also be some kind of security thing where the 7 was designed to be able to have 3rd party access where the 6/6s would have required the secure enclave to do something risky.

Pure guess.

Well, the Secure Enclave is in every device with a TouchID, so that's the iPhone 5S and newer.

Right but I mean that perhaps in the iPhone 7 they somehow rejiggered the SE interface in anticipation of doing this. That way the 7 hardware has a very secure way to do this where as since it wasn't planned in the older phones it might not be secure if they tried to provide access from user software. Maybe the NFC reader is attached to a different chip in the 7 that makes this easier/secure than in the older phones.

Yeah, makes sense

Reply on news.ycombinator.com