The physics dept at CU-D is an utter flaming shit-show currently, fwiw. Hard-pass.
I don't know about the Math at Boulder, but I haven't heard much fair or negative about it. Not enough data to make any conclusions.
AMC is alright, but it's post-undergrad/grad-school only, so anything you hear has that flavor added. Lots of med-y students though, few researchers in small labs (<3 grad students/PI).
CU-CS? No idea, never talked to anyone that graduated there or is there now. Guess that means it's not super good or super bad then, again, not enough data.