Hacker News Reader

Comment by throwanem | Hacker News Reader

I also think gay marriage is a bad idea in general. Were I a Californian citizen, I might well have made a similar donation. Am I also homophobic?

Before you answer, you might like to know I'm gay. Self-hating, no doubt...

View on HN

What was Eich's argument against gay marriage? Does anyone have a link where he fleshed out his position?

Does it matter what his argument was, or whether it differed from mine or Overtonwindow's? If you're willing to assume we have reasonably sensible positions on the matter - I note you haven't inquired into these, in any case - then why not assume that he does, too?

Eich's story comes up frequently on HN, and he's the founder and CEO of a business that someone might choose to support or boycott. The article is about him and his company. It's reasonable for someone to be more interested in his position than yours.

Me too. Gay and opposed to gay marriage.

No kidding? You're the first I've met who shares both the trait and the opinion, or at least the first I'm aware I have.

I know my reasons. What are yours, if I may?

In my opinion, marriage is nothing more than a contract of love and commitment, and I don't need government recognition or acquiescence for it. I also think proponents of gay marriage are more concerned with parity with heterosexual couples, something else I don't need or care. A civil union has worked just fine and asking the government to recognize my union as marriage just doesn't interest me.

Out of interest if it's something you don't need or care about why are you opposed it? You don't care so much you would donate money to oppose it?

The obvious counter is the one already deployed, if only implicitly, in response to your comment - that this analysis is selfish, and says nothing about whether gay marriage is socially valuable, but only whether it's valuable to you.

I spent a day's worth of HN participation arguing against gay marriage, a few months back, and came out net positive in karma. If you're interested in those arguments, they begin here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12976422

Should you take the time, I'd be interested and obliged to hear any thoughts they occasion.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com