Hacker News Reader

Comment by nebula | Hacker News Reader

'Individual rights' in India? I would be pleased if you can point me to something (an event, a case won, etc.,) that highlights the fact that there's hope that eventually India would move towards respecting individual rights.

View on HN

Why don't you show me a counter example of it. See the Sanjay Dutt case. See Salman Khan case, one of country's top 3 stars prisoned for animal rights. Every now and then in newspapers you can read top officials getting penalized for misusing their powers.

I love Indian judicial system, it is terrifically unparalleled.

So is our democracy and individual rights. We had first woman prime minister 25 years back. Just a few years back, our Prime Minister was Sikh and President was Muslim - Both minorities. Tell me when any nation pulls that off.

What makes you think it is not respected now? Are you an Indian. I think my individual rights are fairly well protected (except if i'm in lawless state like Bihar)

I am an Indian and I can point you to a number of incidents involving banning of books, movies and jailing of artists. People jailed for posting anti Sonia Gandhi messages on Orkut[1], banning of the comic Savita Bhabhi[2], seizing of Ask Me servers pre trial[3] are recent relevant examples off the top of my head.

[1] http://www.merinews.com/article/man-jailed-for-posting-obsce...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Savita_Bhabhi#Ban_and_criticism...

[3] http://news.oneindia.in/2010/01/30/data-theft-hc-asks-askme-...

Apart from [3] which I don't have much idea of, the other two instances, the state acted within the framework of the law. Granted that, the orkut case the state cracked down disproportionately. But If i want to criticize sonia gandhi on a blog, I can as long as I keep the language civil. That's what I meant by my comment that my freedoms are fairly well protected.

We do have some very archaic laws and I woud like less censorship on the matters of religion and pornography but even within the current framework of laws a great deal can be done

yes, a former head of state police has been brought to book for molesting a girl who committed suicide when the incident took place. Problem is that it takes so much time for verdicts that its almost justice denied. But there is some effort being there. For instance the 'mission undertrial' that the law minister launched this Feb. Almost 1 lakh accused of petty crimes were just languishing in jails without a hearing, all of them have been released.

Problem here is that we tend to take two steps forward and one step back. I hope that changes.

There are too many things to list, but one that I'm quite proud of is how the courts have legalized homosexuality recently. Granted it's way overdue, but you can see that it was widely appreciated, except for Christian and Muslim institutions, which is to be expected anyway. Sure, you might not have the same level of governance that you see in a first world country. But it's changing, and ever so fast. You only have to be in India and watch the news to observe it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com