Yes, we've "essentially" just gone back in time, but it's not a positive regression.
I agree, but with the way this thing has been reported you'd think we've gone back to the dark ages rather than where we were just prior to the election. I don't recall a lot of discussion on HN about which proxy to use because "OMG my ISP is going to sell my browsing history!!!" back then.
That's all I'm getting at. Wondering why the reaction to going back to the status quo of not long ago at all is seen as some assault on civil liberties.
> There were some ISPs which were selling people's data prior to this order (Verizon was one, IIRC, and a few others were actively injecting ads and JS into non-TLS traffic), and many more were considering it.
edit: spelling
The status quo was wrong, which is why we passed the law in the first place.
The difference, of course, is:
* [thing isn't thought about, so isn't made illegal - making it implicitly legal] * Hey, this thing they're doing is bad - now that we know about it, we should make it illegal. * Repeal: Hey, let them do this thing.
When the articles about ISPs came up (as Verizon did, fairly frequently; though it was also as frequently buried), there was discussion about using VPNs. We're primarily technology users and creators; our first instincts are to find technological solutions to such problems.
Give this a week, and it will fade from the front pages as well. That doesn't mean it's not still important, or that we accept the new status quo as being right or correct.
> Wondering why the reaction to going back to the status quo
Because, IMO, that "status quo" was not a good place to be, and was getting worse. And is now likely to continue to get worse since we've regressed back to it.
We pride ourselves as Americans as being progressive - trying to make things more fair for everyone. Everyone should have a vote. Everyone should be able to express their thoughts without fear of censorship. Everyone should have the ability to rise above their station. Everyone should have a right to privacy. When our elected government take steps away from these ideals, people (rightly, IMO) complain that we're moving in the wrong direction.