Hacker News Reader

Comment by apostacy | Hacker News Reader

Actually, that's not completley true. pv will detect the file size if you use the shell to read a file into it, like pv < file.

View on HN

At first I thought, no, that's not possible. Then I thought, no, they wouldn't do THAT would they?

But I guess they do...

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1734243/in-c-how-do-i-pri...

I've seen that kind of brokenness from programs trying to find their binary image on disk. Don't do it, it's bad.

It doesn't need to hunt for the directory entry, just needs to call `fstat()` on the stdin file descriptor.

Oops you're right, has size in the inode.

Unless the input file is a device, and then you need to call:

    ioctl(STDIN_FILENO, BLKGETSIZE64, &size)

But I guess this is orthogonal to where the file descriptor comes from (i.e. stdin or opening a file whose name is passed in the args)

It's an orthogonal issue, yes, but calling stat or fstat on any block device whether from stdin or argv will return .st_size == 0, so your progress bar won't display the correct answers (or could display better answers if it used the ioctl).

If all they want is the size of the file, then what is wrong with using fstat?

It's not the same thing as trying to walk the FS to look for the filename is silly.

It makes a decent interview question tho', "explain the difference between cat file|./prog and ./prog <file". It doesn't even matter if they get it wrong, that they even know there is a difference is a very good sign.

I think most people wouldn't know the difference (I had no idea!) and the knowledge might fall into the realm of obscure trivia.

People who have come into SA work via being C programmers usually figure it out, they make the best SAs because they are mentally equipped to reason about a system from first principles.

    pv file.bin | dd of=/dev/sdb

is nice too. Honestly while the OP sparks a nice conversation, it is actually complaining about the use of dd out of lack of knowledge.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com