Hacker News Reader

I extensively use closures in Python, particularly jit compiled closures with numba. I don't really have any problems with that, why do you say it's unpythonic?

View on HN

I'm not saying they are, I don't think I've used the language enough to be able to tell what's pythonic and what's not. It's just that I think the language support could be better: why defining a function and calling it right after? That's what lambdas are for.

> why defining a function and calling it right after?

Documentation.

You could have named closures, so that's hardly a valid reason.

We prefer to have only one obvious way to do it. The more good techniques in existence, the less there's a clear sense of "Pythonic".

It's just a preference. Many tasks have more than one obvious way. But if you're asking to add a new feature, you should explain why it's worth the downside of adding yet another way to do it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com