Ask HN: Why are trains not autonomous yet? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Why are trains not autonomous yet?

4 pointsfjahr4 comments

With all the advances in cars and drones it seems like trains should already be traveling without a person in the cockpit. To me it seems surprising that there is not even a discussion about this here in Germany where the was a train crash recently where a train dispatcher was playing a game on his phone and caused the crash because he was not paying attention. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_Aibling_rail_accident

What are the main issues with a technology solutions? Are any startups working on this?

View on HN

I think autonomous trains per-se could work, but even then it would be worthwhile to employ the 1 driver that would even just sit there, as lives of 100s of people are at stake.

There are always "exceptions" to a ride, where a human driver / operator would help, such as a person hitting the emergency button because of a medical condition, violence at the carriage, someone's hand got stuck between the doors etc.

What should actually be is not autonomous trains as we envision autonomous cars, but rather sophisticated signalling and emergency braking automation.

In this day and age, I can't see how come a train is allowed to drive past a red light, depart a stop without supervisor permission or scheduled departure, exceed allowed speed etc. These are very simple things infrastructure can enforce and I don't understand how come it has not been done yet.

I guess it has been done in some train networks. My personal familiarity is with the Melbourne (Australia) train network, and it's very old and untypical to a relatively modern western city.

Docklands Light Railway in London has been driverless for years now.

Trains are autonomous in civilized countries

Then how can accidents like the I mentioned happen due to human error? Two trains crashed because they were both given a green light on the same track by the train dispatcher. That does not sound autonomous to me.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com