Comment by mmphosis | Hacker News Reader

Comment by mmphosis | Hacker News Reader

<rant> Ubuntu eases the transition because I don't have to think (too much) about partitioning the disk. As a "user", I really don't want to ever see disk partitioning software, ever! Although, now I wish /home was in a separate partition -- why wasn't that the default?

I continually trip over the Super key which brings up the Unity version of Spotlight. I killed Spotlight on my Mac a long time ago. I killed whatever Unity thingy the Alt key used to do. Was it the Alt key it hijacked? I don't remember. I don't even remember what weird UI it was trying to foist on me. It was annoying.

I killed the Guest user, but it reappeared with subsequent updates. I still sometimes get logged in as the Guest user, just annoying. And why does the login screen forget the state of the NumLock key? When we type in numbers that might be in our password, we get cursor keyed to the next or previous user in the list. Fun times.

I stopped using LibreOffice. I so much wish I could kill the office ecosystem, it is dreadful. Stop sending me .doc files. My solution is to use an ancient version of Word on an old Mac, and it prompts me so that I can avoid running those Word Macros.

My production server runs Linux (for years now), and I am surprised by how robust it is. A desktop is much more complicated to do well, to satisfy everyone's whims, never mind all of my strange choices.

Not even particularly a desktop issue, but: init cron rc rc.local upstart systemd runit launchd daemontools srvscanner inetd xinetd StartupItems grub2 SystemStarter (I am sure there are many more.) Do I care? No. Ah yes Linux, all of those choices, doesn't even have to be Linux, flavor of the week of BSD anyone? And if I don't like them ... it's open source, so I can "simply" fork my own turd. Not. </rant>

>now I wish /home was on a separate partition

I feel you there. When I first started dipping my toes into Linux at age ~16, I remember the Ubuntu installer asking me all kinds of questions I didn't know the answer to, like "Would you like to repartition your disk?" "Would you like a logical partition or a physical partition?" "What disk would you like to install your bootloader on?" etc. I had no idea how to answer any of these and I just sort of went with the options that sounded safe to me.

It wasn't until several years and versions of Ubuntu later that I decided I wanted to try a different distro and realized how convenient it would have been if I had put /home on its own partition. The whole concept of "you can swap out your OS and leave your files alone" was incomprehensible to me at that point as a lifetime Windows user. Even if it had been the default to split up the partitions, I probably would have set it to stick with just one, because that's how Windows did it.

(Incidentally, I have vivid memories of my grandfather's Windows hard drive, which he had inexplicably partitioned up to at least G:\ and I think L:\. I still don't know why he did this and since he has passed, I probably never will. Our best guess is that it was a habit he picked up from some pre-Windows OS - he was an early tech adopter, but opinionated.)

>all those startup service managers

I haven't used desktop Ubuntu in a while, but after investing some time into grokking Arch and systemd, I'm pretty happy with my idling process list. I'm pretty sure I know what each of them are and how they got there. I'm young enough that I don't miss init, though, so maybe that's just naivete on my part and malicious gluttony on the part of systemd :)

> It wasn't until several years and versions of Ubuntu later that I decided I wanted to try a different distro and realized how convenient it would have been if I had put /home on its own partition.

It's a great idea in theory, but my /home is full of dotfile configs that belong to specific applications - which is great, I can take my configs with me! Except that not all distros have these in the same place. For a given app, some distros will have the config in ~, in ~/.config/, in /etc/, and so on.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com